Business Accountants: Building vs. Buying a House: Weighing the Pros and Cons for Homeowners


In the current real estate landscape marked by rising mortgage rates and limited inventory, the decision of whether to build a house or buy an existing one is more crucial than ever. Prospective homeowners face several considerations, such as costs, maintenance, and energy efficiency, when making this significant choice. To provide clarity, we’ll delve into the pros and cons of both building a new house and purchasing an established home, allowing you to navigate this pivotal decision with confidence.

Pros of Building a House: Building a new house offers a range of appealing advantages, making it an attractive option for both first-time and seasoned homebuyers.

  1. Customization Options: Building from the ground up grants you significant control over your home’s design. From floor plans to finishes and paint colors, you can create your dream home tailored to your personal style and preferences.

  2. No Bidding Wars: Building a house eliminates the competition seen in the current real estate market, where bidding wars on existing homes have become common. With a new build, you can secure your dream home without the stress of competing with other buyers.

  3. Energy Efficiency: Newly constructed homes come equipped with modern appliances and systems, resulting in substantial savings on utility bills. An energy-efficient home not only benefits the environment but also your wallet.

  4. Less Maintenance: New homes feature brand-new appliances, systems, and materials often covered by builder warranties. As a result, you can enjoy a maintenance-free period for a few years, providing peace of mind for both you and your finances.

Cons of Building a House: Despite its advantages, building a home presents some challenges that warrant consideration:

  1. Difficult Financing: Building a house often requires multiple loans, including land loans, construction loans, and traditional mortgages. Obtaining these loans may be challenging without excellent credit or a substantial down payment.

  2. Lengthy and Costly Process: The construction of a home can be a lengthy and expensive process, subject to labor shortages and material delays. Unexpected costs can arise, as contractor estimates are not always precise.

  3. Less Desirable Location: New construction typically occurs in developing areas on the outskirts of town, necessitating a commute to well-established city centers. Desirable locations near amenities are often already taken or built upon.

  4. Increased Effort: Building your dream home involves active participation in the process, including selecting finishes, reviewing contracts, approving changes, and managing finances. Although modern general contractors may use construction management software to streamline tasks, your involvement is essential.

Pros of Buying a House: Purchasing an existing home presents its own set of advantages that may align better with your preferences and circumstances:

  1. Lower Cost: As of June 2023, existing homes tend to be more cost-effective compared to new builds. This often translates to better interest rates and lower down payments, providing savings for homebuyers.

  2. Long Purchase History: Established homes come with a history of purchase, offering insights into potential appreciation value. This historical data helps you make informed decisions about your investment’s future.

  3. Unique Architecture: Older homes boast unique architectural styles, from mid-century to Victorian or Tudor designs, allowing you to enjoy a distinctive property in contrast to the uniformity often found in new developments.

  4. Developed Landscaping: Existing homes typically feature mature landscaping with lush trees and gardens, offering immediate outdoor beauty. In contrast, new builds require additional investment to establish greenery that can take years to flourish.

Cons of Buying a House: Before choosing to buy an existing home, take note of potential disadvantages:

  1. Cost of Maintenance: Older homes may require the replacement of outdated systems, such as roofing, HVAC, electrical, or plumbing, to comply with current safety regulations. Maintenance costs can be significant, and you may encounter foundation issues, termites, and other problems.

  2. Utility Costs: Older homes often feature outdated materials and systems, leading to higher utility expenses compared to modern, energy-efficient homes. Updating these systems to meet current building codes can be a substantial upfront expense.

  3. Bidding Wars: Competition for existing homes can be intense, particularly in sought-after areas. High demand, coupled with low inventory, may result in bidding wars where buyers offer above asking price and forego inspections and appraisals.

  4. Outdated Floor Plans: Older homes tend to have closed-off floor plans with smaller rooms, in contrast to the modern trend of open-concept designs. If you prefer larger, more open spaces, you may need to invest in remodeling or consider building a new home.

The decision of whether to build or buy a house is a significant one, and the right choice depends on your unique preferences and circumstances. Evaluate the pros and cons of each option, and prioritize what matters most to you. Ensure that the challenges associated with your choice are manageable, allowing you to make an informed decision regarding one of the most substantial investments of your life.


Your Outside Team



Need a bit of assistance with your business? Contact an Outside Accounting team member today and learn more about our fixed fees. You won’t regret it.

Aside from business consultation, we are business accountants Wellington who offer accountingbookkeeping, payroll services designed to help you achieve greater financial success.

You can click here to speak to a businessaccounting and bookkeeping firm. We will give you a call to know more about your needs. We will explain to you how we can improve your business. 




Wellington Accountants | 

Business Accountants | 

Construction Accountants 

Property Accountants 

Contractor Accountants 

Hospitality Accountants |

Property Developer Accountants | Accountants Wellington | Wellington Accountant | Restaurant Accountants | Cafe Accountants | Business Consultation | Business Adviser

AddressLevel 2, 182 Vivian Street,
Te Aro, Wellington 6011, New Zealand 

Mail: PO Box 24-457, Wellington 6142

Phone04 889 29 75

New Zealand Accounting, Bookkeeping & Property Business Consultancy Services | Wellington & Lower Hutt Xero Property Accountants Business coach business consultation business adviser

Business Accountants: Understanding Changes in Residential Property Taxation

Recent years have seen significant adjustments to the tax landscape, particularly concerning residential property. The government has responded to calls from various quarters to address investor demand in this sector. Notably, recent changes have been initiated to reverse tax policies affecting residential property, aligning with promises made by both National and ACT during their election campaigns.

Read More »
New Zealand Accounting, Bookkeeping & Property Business Consultancy Services | Wellington & Lower Hutt Xero Property Accountants Business coach business consultation business adviser

Business Accountants: GST on Housing: Avoid Surprise Tax Bills

As we approach May 2024, it’s crucial to address potential GST pitfalls when selling property. Over the past decade, there have been instances where property sellers, unaware of GST implications, faced unexpected tax bills, especially those converting residential properties into holiday rentals or using them for business.

Read More »